On BioScience and Life and Such

Now this is why we need genetic counselors

In Uncategorized on April 25, 2008 at 12:00 pm

After reading “Living at risk: Concealing risk and Preserving Hope“, which was an eye-opening experience, I am ready to argue against myself and the arguments in my previous post “Now why do we need genetic counselors ?”.

In this post I predicted that genetic counselors may soon be obsolete because nobody cares about low-risk alleles. In addition I argued that information on high-risk alleles is better managed by physicians.

The not caring bit is still true (unfortunately) as far as I know, but after reading the above mentioned paper, I need to modify my opinion on high risk tests. High risk tests in this context, are tests that if positive, means developing disease in the near future. Testing for Huntington disease is a model example of such tests since:

“Penetrance, the likelihood of showing symptoms of the disease if the associated genetic mutation is present, is virtually 100%.”

Thus, this is a clear medical case and a physician should be able to give adequate counsel to the patient. But, the issues a practitioner would face are so much more than medicine alone and recommendations for counseling goes wider than what is expected of a primary care physician:

Nearly every participant with children experienced terrible difficulty in talking to their children about their risk, even when the children were grown. We infer from this difficulty that practitioners could, and should, find ways to help people at risk develop plans for educating their children at an appropriate age. We envision such plans to be developmentally based, geared to answering questions at the child’s level, as well as being persistent and gradual in the presentation of the issues of importance.

This to me, sounds like genetic counseling. Further arguments for genetic counseling comes from the recommendations to the clinicians:

Clinicians also need to reflect on their own beliefs and biases about genetic testing, and to examine the extent to which those beliefs and biases present themselves in their care for people at risk for HD. Primary care health professionals need to be cognizant of the fact that just because a test can be done does not mean that it should be done. What these men and women are telling us is that it is not safe to assume that genetic testing for incurable diseases will necessarily provide information that is wanted, or needed, by those at risk and that testing may have a significant negative impact on the lives of their patients.

Objectively reflecting on genetic testing as well as telling the patient that it may actually be wise not to get tested, are probably things a genetic counselor would do better than the primary care physician.

So, the conclusion must be: I was wrong, we need genetic counselors. Reading “Living at risk: Concealing risk and Preserving Hope” will tell you this. In adition it will teach you that 80-85 % of at risk individuals elects not to undertake predictive genetic testing. They do so to survive since a lack of hope can be devastating:

Something that my uncle said, that I think really stuck with me, is he wrote a suicide note. He said that there’s such a big difference between living with hope and living with knowledge. And that he would take the living with hope any day. And so he really did not think we needed to know, one way or another.

…………and, proper counseling (not only genetic) may be a help for people in handling their life at risk since:

It is noteworthy that several participants said the interview for this study was their first opportunity to talk about the emotional side of HD, despite their years of experience with neurological, cognitive, and psychomotor testing …………… We think that unstructured interviews might actually change the views and actions of the participants with respect to their careful concealment of risk and their preservation of hope.

This is probably true. Regardless of the extent of counseling, it seems to me that genetic counseling for these patients and their family members is a good starting point.

The final take home message must be that not testing for a condition has significant value, especially when treatment options are scarce or non-existent.

Hope is sometimes a life saver. Knowledge on the other hand, can put peoples lives in ruins. Use this as a guiding light if you will, – I know I am going to.

  1. […] Now this is why we need genetic counselors …those beliefs and biases present themselves in their care for people at risk for HD. Primary care health professionals need to be cognizant of… […]

  2. Your opinion was wonderful!
    I think you could publish this article in Science 🙂
    The paper is too long, 12 pages, I just read half of it. My major is molecular biology, some concepts in it are indistinct for me. I like graphs and tables, that’s visualized.
    Expecting your new post.

  3. […] Now this is why we need genetic counselors (The SciPhu Weblog): A unique post that was also featured on WordPress.com. […]

  4. Good post and thanks for reading a PredictER paper!

  5. […] Now this is why we need genetic counselors […]

  6. […] my first post where I argued that the need for genetic counselors was overrated. After reading an article on Huntington’s disease however, I changed my mind, and wrote another blog post. But now, […]

  7. […] impact of even the most damning of genetic test-results (Huntington’s, see my previous posts (1, 2, 3) on genetic counseling). That said, patients that feel insecure when faced with their own […]

  8. Iam a physician working in a center for children with special needs .

    my inquiry how to do post gradual study and get certificat for genetic counseler

    thanks for your assistance

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: